|
Dozens of companies make three dimensional digitizers and scanners, and it’s a frequently changing cast of characters. Instruments are available to digitize objects from microscopic in size to entire construction projects or large portions of oil refineries. Data acquisition speeds range from a few points per minute using manual technologies, to more than a million points per second. Prices range from a couple of thousand dollars to hundreds of thousands of dollars. To a great extent this situation reflects the wide range of applications that are presented to this class of devices. But the very exuberance of engineering approaches may also be indicative of an immature market and technology base. Rapid prototyping is another field that exhibits a similarly wide range of technologies, and perhaps it is not a coincidence that reverse engineering may be considered reverse-rapid prototyping.
Digitizers have numerous specifications, but there are just three key ones: volume, accuracy and speed. Volume is self-explanatory, but it should be noted that for most technologies it’s not actually much of a limitation. That’s because it’s possible to stitch together numerous scans using RE software to accommodate objects that are much larger than the available scanning volume. The tradeoff is time and accuracy, however.
Accuracy and resolution are related, but not the same. Accuracy refers to how precisely the measurements correspond to dimensional standards. Resolution specifies the smallest increment of distance or volume that the instrument can measure. It’s possible for an instrument to have high resolution and be inaccurate, and vice versa. Some manufacturers specify one value and not the other, and each uses its own terminology and conditions. Different specifications can apply to each axis of measurement, as well. Accuracy and resolution are the main "weasel clauses" in most digitizer specs. If they are critical to your application, it may be necessary to get further data from the manufacturer or perform certification testing.
Speed is frequently given in points/second. Here again, there is great variation among manufacturers in terminology and conditions. Some manufacturers supply essentially anecdotal specifications or no information at all. Nevertheless, it’s usually possible to at least get an idea of the regimen the instrument falls into.
Back Next
|
 
|